|
Session 3:
Heavy Metals
Can
Standard Sequential Extraction Determinations Effectively
Define Heavy Metal Species in Superfund Site Soil?
Cheryl L. Dahlin, US
Dept of Energy, Albany, OR
Lead
Contamination in Urban Soils
Paul Carroll, US
EPA, Lexington, MA
Measurement
of Oral Arsenic Bioavailability from Soil
Michael Ruby,
Exponent, Boulder, CO
Removal
of Lead from a Calcereous Soil by Chloride Chelation
Wayne J. Parker,
Carleton University, Ottawa, Ontario
Reduction
and Immobilization of Chromium (VI) in Groundwater Using
Nanoscale Iron Particles
Jiasheng Cao, Lehigh
University, Bethelehem, PA
Lead
Pollution in Firing Ranges
Nektaria Menounou,
Stevens Institute of Technology, Hoboken, NJ
Retrospective
Study of Mercury in Museum and Modern Specimens of the
American Raccoon, Procyon lotor, in Southern
Florida
Ed Zillioux, FPL
Environmental Services, Juno Beach, FL
Can
Standard Sequential Extraction Determinations Effectively
Define Heavy Metal Species in Superfund Site Soils?
Cheryl L. Dahlin, Connie A. Williamson, W. Keith
Collins, and David. C. Dahlin, US Department of Energy,
Albany Research Center
Speciation and distribution of heavy metals in soils
controls the degree to which metals and their compounds
are mobile, extractable, and plant-available.
Consequently, speciation impacts the success of
remediation efforts both by defining the relationship of
the contaminants with their environment and by guiding
development and evaluation of workable remediation
strategies. The U.S. Department of Energy, Albany Research
Center (Albany, OR), under a two-year interagency project
with the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA),
examined the suitability of sequential extraction as a
definitive means to determine species of heavy metals in
soil samples. Representative soil samples, contaminated
with lead, arsenic, and/or chromium, were collected by EPA
personnel from two Superfund sites, the National Lead
Company site in Pedricktown, NJ, and the Roebling Steel,
Inc., site in Florence, NJ. Data derived from Tessier=s
standard three-stage sequential-extraction procedure were
compared to data from a comprehensive characterization
study that combined optical- and scanning-electron
microscopy (with energy-dispersive x-ray and wavelength-dispersive
x-ray analyses), x-ray diffraction, and chemical analyses.
The results show that standard sequential-extraction
procedures that were developed for characterizing species
of contaminants in river sediments may be unsuitable for
sole evaluation of contaminant species in industrial-site
materials (particularly those that contain larger
particles of the contaminants, encapsulated contaminants,
and/or man-made materials such as slags, metals, and
plastics). However, each sequential extraction or
comprehensive characterization procedure has it=s own
strengths and weaknesses. Findings of this study indicate
that the use of both approaches, during the early stages
of site studies, would be a best practice. The
investigation also highlights the fact that an effective
speciation study does not simply identify metal
contaminants as specific chemical compounds but also
defines their variations in chemistry, size, associations,
concentrations, porosity, adsorption, liberation,
fracturing, alteration (products and potential), and host
materials.
Lead
Contamination in Urban Soils
Paul Carroll, M.S., USEPA, H. Patricia Hynes, M.S.,
Boston University School of Public Health, and Rob
Maxfield, M.S., USEPA.
In-situ measurements were made at more than 100
properties in low-income neighborhoods around Greater
Boston to identify and delineate lead (Pb) contamination
in these urban residential soils as part of the Lead Safe
Yard Program (LSYP). The LSYP is an EPA/EMPACT funded
program designed as a pilot study to develop on-site soil
lead monitoring, low-cost remedial landscape techniques,
and educational and instructive materials for reducing
children's exposure to lead in soil in a high risk urban
neighborhood. The program uses innovative field portable
X-ray fluorescence spectrometry (FPXRF) methods to collect
these in-situ measurements and low cost/no cost
landscape-based mitigation methods to reduce the risk of
human exposure to elevated levels of Pb in these
residential soils. We present field data (n=2784) focusing
on typical findings at an urban residential property and
background levels of lead in soil for this urban setting.
QC data, focusing on sensitivity, and precision and
accuracy, will also be presented to demonstrate that FPXRF
is an excellent tool to delineate lead contamination in
urban soils at concentrations suitable for evaluation
against current health based standards.
Measurement
of Oral Arsenic Bioavailability from Soil
Michael V. Ruby, Yvette W. Lowney, Exponent; Stephen M.
Roberts, University of Florida; Rosalind A. Schoof,
Gradient Corporation
This presentation will discuss the state of the science
with regard to measuring the oral bioavailability of
arsenic in soil. Currently, there are two animal models
available for measuring relative arsenic bioavailability
from soil: the young swine model developed by U.S. EPA
Region VIII at the University of Missouri-Columbia, and a
Cebus monkey model developed at the University of Florida
on behalf of the Florida Department of Environmental
Protection. The design characteristics of these two models
will be reviewed, with particular attention to their
environmental relevance and the manner in which they mimic
incidental human exposures to arsenic in soil. Arsenic
bioavailability estimates obtained with these two models
will be discussed.
This talk will also review a study that is underway to
measure relative arsenic bioavailability from 7–10
additional soils in the Cebus monkey model. These soils
derive from mining, milling, smelting, refinery, pesticide
manufacturing, and orchard sites, and were selected to
obtain a range of arsenic forms and soil types. In
addition, the two in vivo models will be compared
by testing in monkeys, or swine, a minimum of three soils
previously tested in the other in vivo model. The
ultimate goal of this research effort is to develop a
robust in vivo database against which an in
vitro extraction test can be validated. Progress
towards achieving this goal will also be discussed.
Removal
of Lead from a Calcareous Soil by Chloride Chelation
S. Wasay, W Parker, P. Van
Geel, Carleton University, Ottawa, Ontario
This study addressed the use of chloride as a chelating
agent for the selective removal of lead from a calcareous
soil. The test soil employed in this study was
contaminated by lead-acid battery waste. A component of
the study focussed upon the use of precipitating agents
for treatment of the soil extracts thereby allowing
recycling of the leaching solution. In the soil under
study, the Pb concentration in the particle sizes smaller
than 4.75 mm was found to be 3,200 mg/kg, and the calcium
concentration was found to be 85,700 mg/kg. A finer
fraction of the soil (£ 2.0 mm) contained 13,200 and
155,200 mg/kg of Pb and Ca respectively. With a NaCl
concentration of 8 M the removal of Pb was found to be 83%
while 9% of the Ca was removed. Multiple extractions of Pb
with 8 M NaCl were performed and the removal of Pb was
found to 93% after six successive extractions. The removal
of Pb increased with time in a batch test and approached
80% after 90 h. Increasing removal of Pb was found as the
water/soil ratio was increased at a constant concentration
of NaCl. The addition of 25 g/L of lime, 4.5 g/L of sodium
carbonate, and 8.2 g/L of calcium carbonate to the soil
extract resulted in Pb removals of 90, 99.7, and 35%
respectively. In the case of sodium carbonate, the removal
efficiency of Pb was further improved when the pH was
adjusted to 8.2. The recycling of free chloride generated
from the extract in a remediation process revealed that
91% of Pb was removed from the soil (particle size £ 4.75
mm) after six cycles.
Reduction
and Immobilization of Chromium(VI) in Groundwater Using
Nanoscale Iron Particles
Jiasheng Cao and Wei-xian Zhang, Lehigh University
Remediation of chromium contaminated soil and
groundwater remains a formidable technical challenge due
to the high mobility and toxicity of chromium (VI) in
ground water. Herein we report the transformation of Cr(VI)
in contaminated groundwater and soil to Cr(III) with
subsequent immobilization using nanoscale iron particles.
Several bench scale batch and column tests were conducted
to determine the rate and extent of Cr(VI) reduction with
the nanoscale iron particles. Parallel experiments were
also conducted with commercial iron filings (100 mesh).
Cr(VI) was found reduced instantaneously to Cr(III). The
kinetic of Cr(VI) reduction by zero-valent iron in aqueous
solution is pseudo-first-order. The rate of Cr(VI)
reduction by nanoscal iron particles is at least 20-40
times greater than that with commercial iron fillings. In
water-soil slurries, the transformation of Cr(VI) is
complicated by the reactions taking place both in solution
and at the water-solid interfaces. Data clearly
demonstrate that the transformation of Cr(VI) is highly
dependent on solution pH. For example, Cr(VI) desorbs
rapidly from soil to aqueous solution. However, reductive
reaction rate is slow. Continuous flow column tests were
also conducted to simulate in situ injection, transport
and reactions of nanoscale iron particles in the
subsurface. The particles were injected into the soil
column (0.02 g nanoparticle/g soil) along with chromium
contaminated underground water (CCr(VI) = 43.8
ppm). Over 99% of the Cr(VI) in soil and underground water
was reduced and immobilized. The results suggest that
nanoscale iron particles appear to be highly effective for
the remediation of chromium contaminated sites.
Lead
Pollution in Firing Ranges
Dimitris Dermatas and Nektaria Menounou, Stevens
Institute of Technology
Lead soil contamination is an environmental problem in
army firing ranges. In particular, training or shooting
range areas are an important component of the military
activities but on the same time they adversely impact the
environment. There is inevitable buildup of bullets and
residues of other related activities in impact areas and
therefore ranges are potential source areas for lead and
other heavy metals and other contaminants. If left
unattended, the metals may be transported into the
environment via various pathways. This study was performed
to evaluate the extent of the problem and the fate of lead
in selected firing range soils. Both total digestion and
toxicity characteristics leaching procedure (TCLP)
experiments were conducted to examine lead presence and
mobility. These tests indicated that high concentrations
of lead were generally present and that the soil leached
more lead than what is acceptable under EPA regulations.
In some cases TCLP-Pb was as high as 300 mg/L. Lead was
also measured in selected particle size ranges in the
soil. Different quantities and particle size distribution
of lead will likely be encountered depending up on weapons
fired and projectile backstop/ impact surface. In this
study, higher quantities of lead were found at the –#10+40
group for most of the samples tested. This is critical in
assessing potential remedial alternatives.
Retrospective
Study of Mercury in Museum and Modern Specimens of the
American Raccoon, Procyon lotor, in Southern
Florida
Edward J Zillioux, Florida Power & Light Company,
Donald B. Porcella, Environmental Science &
Management, Thomas M. Grieb, Tetra Tech, James R. Newman,
Pandion Systems, Geoffrey B. West, Florida Power &
Light Company
An historic perspective on mercury in biota is
important to identify factors that control its
accumulation. Raccoons are an important food source for
certain mammals, especially including the endangered
species, the Florida Panther, when preferred upland prey
is scarce. We selected five areas in Florida, mostly south
of US Highway 41 (south of latitude 26 oN), as
appropriate sources of historic (museum – most from
1939-1957, six from 1990) and modern (1999-2000) samples:
the Shark Valley Slough (SVS), the Ten Thousand Islands, (Chokolosksee
Bay area (CB) area, the Flamingo area (FLM), Long Pine Key
(LPK), and North Key Largo (NKL). Sites were based in part
on where the museum samples had been collected. Modern
collections were designed to provide nearly equal numbers
of museum and modern specimens, totaling respectively, 14
and 19 (SVS), 25 and 25 (CB), 20 and 21 (FLM), 9 and 11 (LPK),
and 15 and 17 (NKL) in North Key Largo. A total of 209
specimens (91 museum and 118 modern) were analyzed for a
variety of chemicals in addition to monomethylmercury (MMHg).
Hair provides a good archive for MMHg, which constitutes
more than 95 percent of the total Hg in hair. Also, hair
MMHg correlates well with concentrations in many tissues
(heart, blood, brain, kidney, and muscle), and therefore
can act asrepresent the principal variable to understand
the role of raccoons in transferring mercury. Liver MMHg
is relatively low and invariable and does not correlate
well with other tissues. Substantial quality control
analyses show the results are high quality. Collection of
modern samples from comparable locations and habitats as
historic samples increases confidence that temporal
differences can be seen. For example, a preliminary
inspection of comparable SVS data (between latitudes 25
o 38’ to 25 o 46’N) suggests that
mean levels of hair mercury occurring in animals from 1990
(n=6) are c. about 6-fold higher than in specimens from
the 1940s (n=8) and c.about 3-fold higher than in the 2000
animals (n=8). We will draw present conclusions about
raccoon historic and modern Hg levels at the conference.
Top
|