Reducing Uncertainty in DNAPL Characterization
Andrew Bittner, M. Eng. Gradient Corporation,
Cambridge
,
MA
Kurt Herman, M. Eng. Gradient Corporation,
Cambridge
,
MA
Characterization
of a VOC Plume Migrating from Fractured Shale into a
Karst Limestone Aquifer
Paul G. Landry, P.G., Technical Manager, Weston
Solutions, Inc.,
W. Chester
,
PA
Paul R. Stone, III, Project Manager,
U.S.
Army Corps of Engineers,
Chambersburg
,
PA
Bryan L. Hoke, BRAC Environmental Coordinator,
Chambersburg
,
PA
Geophysics
for Fun and Profit:
How to Manage Your Due Diligence Risk
Jesse N. Japitana, ENSR, Westford, MA
Robert M. Cataldo, ENSR, Westford, MA
Optimization
of the Removal of a Volatile Organic Compound
(VOC)-Impacted Source Area through
Pre-Characterization
Jeremy J. Picard, Environmental Resources
Management,
Boston,
MA
Jason D. Flattery Environmental Resources
Management,
Boston,
MA
Louis J. Burkhardt, Raytheon Company, Billerica, MA
Wavelets
and Spectral Analysis, Powerful Tools for Estimating
Aquifer Hydraulic Parameters without Extracting Water
Farid Achour Ph.D., ENVIRON International
Corporation, Irvine, CA
Carol Serlin PG., ENVIRON International Corporation, Irvine,
CA
Reducing
Uncertainty in DNAPL Characterization
Andrew Bittner, M. Eng. Gradient
Corporation,
20 University Road,
Cambridge, MA, 02138, USA, Tel: 617-395-5574, Fax: 617-395-5001, Email:
abittner@gradientcorp.com
Kurt Herman, M. Eng. Gradient
Corporation,
20 University Road,
Cambridge
,
MA
,
02138
,
USA
, Tel: 617-395-5568, Fax: 617-395-5001, Email: kherman@gradientcorp.com
Defining DNAPL extent and magnitude is critical for
successful remedy decision-making.
Inadequate DNAPL characterization may lead to
inappropriate remedy selection and, ultimately, to a
failed or ineffective remedy (i.e., does not
efficiently achieve remedial goals).
We have developed two distinct techniques (one
based on analytical data and the other on visual
observations) to delineate DNAPL extent and magnitude
(mass) and combined the results to minimize
uncertainty. As
a case study, both techniques were applied at a former
manufactured gas plant site with sediments impacted
with tar and its constituents [e.g., polycyclic
aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs)].
For the analytical data approach, we estimated
the extent of the DNAPL by comparing all measured
sediment PAH concentration data with site-specific
solubility limits; we then used all of the PAH
concentrations within the delineated zone to estimate
the mass of tar at the site.
For the visual observation approach, we used
field-recorded observations of DNAPL from sediment
cores to estimate extents.
We then calculated the total DNAPL mass by
assigning representative DNAPL saturation levels.
Individually, each source characterization
approach may have uncertainties, but using both
allowed us to more confidently estimate the DNAPL
extent and mass, which will lead to more appropriate
remedy decisions.
Characterization
of a VOC Plume Migrating from Fractured Shale into a
Karst Limestone Aquifer
Paul G. Landry, P.G., Technical Manager,
Weston Solutions, Inc., 1400 Weston Way, W.
Chester, PA 19380, Tel: 610-701-7273, Email: P.Landry@westonsolutions.com
Paul R. Stone, III, Project Manager, U.S. Army
Corps of Engineers, Letterkenny Army Depot, 1 Overcash
Ave, Chambersburg, PA
17201, Tel: 717-261-6863, Email: Pstone3@kuhncom.net
Bryan L. Hoke, BRAC Environmental Coordinator,
Letterkenny Army Depot, 1 Overcash Ave, Building 14,
Chambersburg, PA 17201,
Tel: 717-267-9836, Email: bhoke@emh1.lead.army.mil
Delineation
of the NAPL source zone in the vicinity of an oil burn
pit (OBP) at Letterkenny Army Depot (LEAD) revealed
the presence of source material on both sides of a
nearby groundwater divide resulting in a bilobate
plume. While
the northern lobe of the plume migrating from the OBP
had been well defined, the southern lobe of the plume
had been previously undetected.
An investigation was initiated to determine
whether the southern lobe of the plume had reached the
Pinola Fault (900 ft downgradient), the formation
contact between the Martinsburg Shale and the St. Paul
Limestone, and if so, what impacts the plume was
having on groundwater/surface water quality in the
limestone aquifer.
Dye tracing and aquifer tests had shown
significant differences in groundwater velocities
between the two rock types (ie; ft/year in the shale
versus >2,000 ft/day in the limestone).
The
migration pathway and extent of the plume moving south
was mapped using geoprobe/soil gas sampling, and
verified by well installations.
The soil gas results correlated extremely well
with the travel path and extent of the contaminated
groundwater within the shale.
The strong soil gas/groundwater quality
correlation was attributed to both shallow groundwater
and slow velocities within the shale, which allowed
for the accumulation of soil gas vapors.
In this manner, the plume was effectively
mapped down to the fault contact and the plume entry
location into the limestone was identified.
VOC sampling results to date indicate minimal
impact from the plume on limestone groundwater
quality. Rapid
groundwater velocities and extensive karst development
result in significant declines in contaminant levels a
short distance from the fault.
Dye tracing results from wells at the plume
entry location and at numerous downgradient wells
throughout the limestone basin appear to substantiate
these findings.
Geophysics
for Fun and Profit:
How to Manage Your Due Diligence Risk
Jesse N. Japitana, ENSR,
2 Technology Park Drive,
Westford
,
MA
,
01886
,
USA
, Tel: 978-589-3000 x 3394, Fax: 978-589-3705, Email:
jjapitana@ensr.aecom.com
Robert M. Cataldo, ENSR,
2 Technology Park Drive,
Westford
,
MA
,
01886
,
USA
, Tel: 978-589-3000 x 3141, Fax: 978-589-3705, Email:
rcataldo@ensr.aecom.com
Near-surface geophysics
provides an efficient, cost-effective and non-invasive
method for the investigation and assessment of
property transfers.
When sequenced, implemented, and integrated
properly, geophysics can enhance our understanding of
site specific subsurface conditions to optimize
further intrusive investigation and corrective action.
Having geophysical data allows for a more
informed decision-making process when evaluating the
benefits and potential liabilities associated with
property acquisition.
This presentation
focuses on geophysics as an innovative technical
approach to manage risk and optimize site
investigations. In
addition, the presentation draws on case studies where
geophysical investigations were used to confirm
suspected underground features or identify previously
unknown hazards that would have significantly impacted
the development cost and timing of these sites had
their existence not been detected.
Optimization
of the Removal of a Volatile Organic Compound
(VOC)-Impacted Source Area through
Pre-Characterization
Jeremy J. Picard, Environmental Resources
Management, 399 Boylston Street, Boston, MA
02116, Tel: 617-646-7800,
Fax: 617-267-6447,
Email: jeremy.picard@erm.com
Jason D. Flattery, Environmental Resources
Management,
399 Boylston Street
,
Boston
,
MA
02116, Tel: 617-646-7800,
Fax: 617-267-6447,
Email: jason.flattery@erm.com
Louis J. Burkhardt, Raytheon Company, 880
Technology Park Drive,
MS
2-2124-01, Billerica, MA
01821, Tel: 978-436-8238,
Fax: 978-436-8581,
Email: Louis_J_Burkhardt@raytheon.com
A
comprehensive characterization is not typically
conducted following source area delineation.
However, pre-characterizing a soil excavation
area may yield benefits to a project including: 1)
reducing the need for real-time analytical data to
support decision-making; 2) allowing for source area
soil to be stockpiled based on the detailed
characterization data, thereby minimizing the mixing
of contaminated and uncontaminated soil; 3) reducing
project uncertainties and capping project costs; and
4) reducing the total volume of soil for disposal at a
waste treatment facility.
At
this subject site the source area soil was delineated
using the United States Environmental Protection
Agency (EPA) Triad Approach, utilizing a combination
of 13 Waterloo Profiler locations, 41 Membrane
Interface Probe (MIP) locations, and 20 soil borings.
A source area of approximately 25 foot (ft)
vertical thickness over an 80 x 80 square foot (ft2)
area was delineated.
The maximum TCE concentration in the source
area soil was 57,000 milligrams per kilogram (mg/kg),
significantly greater than the regulatory standard of
300 mg/kg. Excavation
of the source area soil utilizing a circular sheet
pile cofferdam was determined to be the preferred
remedial approach.
Prior
to initiating the remedial approach, continuous soil
cores were collected from 41 locations within the
excavation area. These
cores were field screened for VOCs and a total of 132
soil samples were submitted VOCs analysis.
The resulting analytical data was used to
optimize the performance of the excavation through a
better understanding of VOC existence within the
source area soils.
Wavelets
and Spectral Analysis, Powerful Tools for Estimating
Aquifer Hydraulic Parameters without Extracting Water
Farid Achour
Ph.D., ENVIRON International Corporation, 2010 Main
Street, Suite 900, Irvine, CA 92614, Tel:
949-798-3622, Fax 949-261-6202, Email: fachour@environcorp.com
Carol Serlin PG., ENVIRON International
Corporation,
2010 Main Street, Suite 900
,
Irvine
,
CA
92614
, Tel: 949-798-3660, Fax 949-261-6202, Email: cserlin@environcorp.com
A
pumping test involves removing ground water from a
well and measuring water levels in the pumping well
and surrounding piezometers. When the aquifer is
contaminated, the extracted water is to be handled
with care. A successful pump test requires time,
effort and pump testing equipment, ranging from the
pump itself to the holding tank and treatment of the
contaminated water, this results in a costly and
tedious operation. However, there are alternatives to
the standard pump test that are cost effective and
“environmentally friendly."
By
analyzing the influence of solid Earth tides and
atmospheric pressure on ground water natural
fluctuation at a contaminated site in southern
California, ENVIRON International Corporation
developed a methodology to estimate aquifer parameters
such as hydraulic conductivity, barometric efficiency,
porosity, specific storage coefficient and storage
coefficient. These hydraulic parameters were
calculated using tools such as Morlet wavelets,
correlation and spectral analyses, gain and coherence
functions, and Bredehoeft model.
The
originality of this approach is that unlike the
traditional approaches developed by Theis and Jacob
for porous media and Gringarten and Witherspoon for
fractured media, where several
a priori assumptions are made (Aquifer is
isotropic, infinite in lateral extent, horizontal, and
uniform thickness....), the proposed approach
considers the response of ground water level within a
well to an external event, indeed, the system is
investigated according to it’s response to an event
without making any assumption on the lithology,
geometry, structure
and voids distribution in the geological
formation.
The
main advantage of the approach is that it allows the
estimation of the above mentioned hydraulic parameters
in multiple wells within a short time, leading to an
accurate characterization of spatial heterogeneities,
therefore efficiently characterize and remediate the
site by providing a better understanding of rates and
directions of groundwater flow and contaminant
transport.